Oil & Gas Litigation Analysis
Home Cases Tawes v. Barnes
Royalty Disputes

Tawes v. Barnes

Texas Supreme Court 10-0581 resolved

The Texas Supreme Court held that an oil and gas lessor could not enforce a Joint Operating Agreement (JOA) to recover unpaid royalties from a non-operating working interest owner who consented to drilling operations, finding the lessor was neither a third-party beneficiary of the JOA's royalty provisions nor in privity of estate with the consenting party. The decision clarifies the strict requirements for third-party beneficiary status under Texas law and confirms that JOA royalty allocation provisions among working interest owners do not create enforceable rights for lessors outside the parties to those agreements.

Analysis