We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Attempting to reconnect
Roxo Energy Company, LLC v. Baxsto, LLC
The Texas Supreme Court held that a mineral lessor's fraud claims failed where alleged oral representations about development intent and bonus payments directly contradicted the unambiguous terms of a paid-up lease granting the lessee an unqualified right to transfer. The Court found reliance unjustifiable as a matter of law when a written agreement's substance conflicts with extra-contractual representations, even absent explicit contradictory language.
Analysis
Texas Supreme Court Bars Fraud Claims When Paid-Up Lease Terms Contradict Oral Development Promises
The Texas Supreme Court held that a mineral lessor could not justifiably rely on a lessee's alleged oral representations about development intent and bonus payments when the parties executed a paid-up lease giving the lessee an unqualified right to transfer the lease without drilling. The Court reinforced that reliance on extra-contractual representations is unjustifiable as a matter of law when a written agreement's express terms directly contradict those oral promises.
Texas Supreme Court Reinforces Parol Evidence Bar in Mineral Lease Fraud Claims
The Texas Supreme Court held that a mineral lessor's fraud claims failed where alleged oral representations about development intent and bonus payments directly contradicted the unambiguous terms of a paid-up lease granting the lessee an unqualified right to transfer. The Court found reliance unjustifiable as a matter of law when a written agreement's substance conflicts with extra-contractual representations, even absent explicit contradictory language.