We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Attempting to reconnect
Robert S. May v. INEOS USA Oil & Gas LLC
The Texas Business Court held that farmees in a farmout agreement acquire a vested fee simple determinable interest immediately upon execution, not upon completion of drilling obligations, rejecting the farmors' argument that the instruments were mere conditional assignments. Judge Sharp ruled that earned-acreage requirements function as special limitations and that payout calculations under the farmout must be tied exclusively to earning wells rather than subsequent non-earning wells drilled on already-earned acreage.
Analysis
Texas Business Court Rules Farmout Agreements Convey Immediate Fee Simple Determinable Interest, Limits Payout to Earning Wells
The Texas Business Court held that farmees in a farmout agreement acquire a vested fee simple determinable interest immediately upon execution, not upon completion of drilling obligations, rejecting the farmors' argument that the instruments were mere conditional assignments. Judge Sharp ruled that earned-acreage requirements function as special limitations and that payout calculations under the farmout must be tied exclusively to earning wells rather than subsequent non-earning wells drilled on already-earned acreage.
Texas Business Court Holds Farmout Agreement Conveyed Fee Simple Determinable Interest Immediately, Rules Retained-Acreage Provisions Are Special Limitations
Texas Business Court holds farmout agreement conveyed fee simple determinable interest in Eagle Ford Shale leases immediately upon execution, rejecting farmor's argument that title passed only after drilling performance, and rules retained-acreage provisions operate as special limitations causing automatic partial termination upon cessation of continuous drilling operations. Court further holds payout calculation for 30% reversionary back-in interest must be computed earning-well-by-earning-well, foreclosing farmor's theory that non-earning wells could independently trigger payout obligations.