Oil & Gas Litigation Analysis
Home Cases NGL Water Solutions Permian, LLC v. Lime Rock Resources V-A, L.P.
Environmental

NGL Water Solutions Permian, LLC v. Lime Rock Resources V-A, L.P.

Texas Business Court, Eleventh Division 25-BC11B-0005 active

NGL Water Solutions sought declaratory relief in Harris County based on a venue-selection clause in a Shut In Agreement, arguing it immunized the company from liability for alleged wastewater migration that damaged Lime Rock's Bone Spring formation wells in Loving County. The Business Court transferred venue to Loving County, holding that Section 15.011's mandatory venue provision for actions to recover damages to real property superseded the contractual forum selection clause, which failed to qualify as a "major transaction" under Section 15.020(a).

Analysis

Business Court Applies Mandatory Venue Rule to Declaratory Judgment Action Over Saltwater Disposal Well Damage in Loving County

NGL Water Solutions sought declaratory relief in Harris County based on a venue-selection clause in a Shut In Agreement, arguing it immunized the company from liability for alleged wastewater migration that damaged Lime Rock's Bone Spring formation wells in Loving County. The Business Court transferred venue to Loving County, holding that Section 15.011's mandatory venue provision for actions to recover damages to real property trumped the contractual forum selection clause, which failed to qualify as a "major transaction" under Section 15.020.

Joel Reese  |  Jul 20, 2026
Permian Basin Subsurface Trespass Saltwater Disposal Mandatory Venue Formation Damage

Texas Business Court Applies Mandatory Real Property Venue Rule to Saltwater Disposal Well Contamination Dispute

NGL Water Solutions sought declaratory relief in Harris County based on a venue-selection clause in a Shut In Agreement, arguing it immunized the company from liability for alleged wastewater migration that damaged Lime Rock's Bone Spring formation wells in Loving County. The Business Court transferred venue to Loving County, holding that Section 15.011's mandatory venue provision for actions to recover damages to real property superseded the contractual forum selection clause, which failed to qualify as a "major transaction" under Section 15.020(a).

Joel Reese  |  Jul 06, 2026
Permian Basin Texas Business Court Surface Damage Saltwater Disposal Mandatory Venue