Oil & Gas Litigation Analysis
Home Cases Lud R. Davis III and Charlotte Davis v. Aethon Energy Operating LLC, et al.
Royalty Disputes

Lud R. Davis III and Charlotte Davis v. Aethon Energy Operating LLC, et al.

Court of Appeals of Texas, Tyler 12-24-00336-CV resolved

The Tyler Court of Appeals affirmed a take-nothing judgment against royalty owners Lud R. Davis III and Charlotte Davis, who alleged that Aethon Energy violated their lease terms by improperly accounting for post-production transportation fees charged by affiliate Scona LLC. The Davises challenged AUBR's practice of showing transportation charges as '$0.00' on 2020 check stubs while allegedly embedding the actual fees in reduced sales prices, but the court found sufficient evidence to support the judgment in AUBR's favor.

Analysis