Oil & Gas Litigation Analysis
Home Cases Kent B. Hoffman, et al. v. Andrew M. Thomson, et al.
Royalty Disputes

Kent B. Hoffman, et al. v. Andrew M. Thomson, et al.

Court of Appeals of Texas, San Antonio 04-19-00771-CV resolved

In a declaratory judgment action originating in McMullen County, the Court of Appeals reversed the trial court's determination that a 1956 deed reserved a fixed 3/32 nonparticipating royalty interest, holding instead that the deed's double fraction language reserved a floating ¾ interest for the grantors. The court applied the presumption that references to ⅛ in deeds containing double fractions serve as shorthand for the lessor's entire mineral estate, rejecting arguments that this presumption was inapplicable to royalty interest reservations or to instruments executed after 1924.

Analysis