Oil & Gas Litigation Analysis
Home Cases Chieftain Royalty Company v. EnerVest Energy Institutional Fund XIII-A, L.P.
Royalty Disputes

Chieftain Royalty Company v. EnerVest Energy Institutional Fund XIII-A, L.P.

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit 24-6227 and 24-6228 resolved

The Tenth Circuit affirmed a $17.3 million attorneys' fee award—33.33% of a $52 million settlement fund—in an Oklahoma royalty underpayment class action, holding that district courts may exceed the 30% guideline established in Strack v. Classen where case complexity and near-complete class certification success warrant departure. The decision rejects objectors' argument that Strack imposed a hard ceiling on percentage-of-fund awards in common-fund fee applications, preserving district court discretion under Oklahoma's statutory fee factors.

Analysis