Oil & Gas Litigation Analysis
Home Cases Bright & Company v. Holbein Family Mineral Trust
Royalty Disputes

Bright & Company v. Holbein Family Mineral Trust

Court of Appeals of Texas, San Antonio 04-98-00674-CV resolved

The San Antonio Court of Appeals held that a lessee's letter and production charts acknowledging $22,268.20 in unpaid gas royalties from 1987-1995 created an implied promise to pay that tolled the four-year statute of limitations under Texas Civil Practice & Remedies Code § 16.065. The court rejected Bright & Company's counterclaim for offset based on alleged overpayments during a different time period, finding it was an untimely counterclaim rather than an affirmative defense that would negate the lessor's right to recover.

Analysis